2 Comments
User's avatar
Erhan Civelek's avatar

Stein is right that pressure is over-valued in the Fraud Triangle - but the deeper issue isn’t just to add psycho-history to the model. It’s to notice which element of the Triangle is actually available to system designers. Rationalization and pressure involve individual psychology that’s largely opaque until after the fact. Opportunity is determined by structure, and structure is the one element you can close before knowing anything about which particular individual will face a pressure they can’t manage. That’s what makes the individual-psychology question both necessary and insufficient: even a complete map of why one person resists and another doesn’t leaves you unable to predict who the rationalizer will be before they rationalize.

Claudine Cassar's avatar

That's a very good distinction. Organisations cannot reliably predict who will rationalise misconduct, but they can design systems that make misconduct harder to commit. I would add, though, that organisational culture also determines whether those controls work in practice. Even well-designed safeguards can fail when people feel unable to challenge decisions, raise concerns or say no. Which brings us back to the psychology Stein is exploring.