5 Comments
User's avatar
Dr Peter Collins's avatar

The great irony of KPMG and its 'selling' of protection of whistleblowing is not lost. Yet a question remains why the APSC just kept going with the contract until it was raised in the media. As an ethicist who ran a national ethics centre, the public sector can outsources its ethics to a big four or other group to provide services without questioning or conducting due diligence. I can't find who now runs same. Some of the other smaller consultancies are as bad as the big four. If you could find that out, it would be a story in itself.

Claudine Cassar's avatar

Peter, the interesting detail is that the APSC actually terminated the contract in July, although this only became public at Senate estimates in October. The Commission said it would complete the training internally. But your broader point about due diligence is an important one. When public institutions outsource ethics training, how thoroughly do they scrutinise the ethical record of the organisations they engage? And are smaller consultancies necessarily any better?

Astrid Yee-Sobraques's avatar

"The evidence therefore points not simply to the actions of individual leaders, but to structural conditions that allowed departures from the firm’s values and expectations to persist." We keep coming back to structural conditions as necessary to the successful discharge of not only ethics, but also risk and compliance responsibilities.

Claudine Cassar's avatar

Exactly. When the same problems keep recurring, it becomes increasingly difficult to attribute them to individual failings. The question is whether the organisation's governance structures, incentives and power dynamics genuinely support ethical behaviour, or whether they make it difficult for those responsible for ethics, risk and compliance to challenge the people at the top.

Claudine Cassar's avatar

Exactly, Astrid. Organisations can have sophisticated ethics policies, risk frameworks and compliance functions, yet still fail when those mechanisms come into conflict with commercial interests or senior leadership. The real test is not whether the structures exist, but whether they have the independence and authority to challenge those at the top.