KPMG’s global head of consulting has acknowledged that artificial intelligence is undermining a business that once generated substantial revenue for professional-services firms: selling advice.
In a 12 November interview with CNBC, Svilena Tzekova explained that clients can now obtain knowledge and advice that previously required days or months of consulting work.
“We were making quite a lot of money by providing advice. I think that part of our business is literally nonexistent anymore.”
The Big Four have spent decades building their consulting businesses around a model that combines partner expertise with large teams of junior professionals. Partners sell the work, while teams of less experienced consultants carry out research, analyse data, prepare presentations and deliver projects. This structure has allowed the firms to generate substantial revenue from the junior employees who power the Big Four machine.
AI is now challenging that model. Clients can increasingly perform research and analysis themselves.
The firms have not been caught unprepared. They recognised AI’s potential to disrupt professional services and have invested heavily in developing AI capabilities, forming partnerships with technology companies and integrating the technology into their operations.
They are now changing how they charge clients, organise their operations, reward partners and train their people.
Clients gain the upper hand
Corporate clients are already using AI to challenge the cost of external consulting.
An investigation by the Financial Times found that companies were demanding lower fees, bringing work in-house and reconsidering their reliance on large consulting teams.
At German pharmaceutical group Bayer, 30 AI agents are supporting coding and testing during a six-year SAP transformation. Jochen Kamp, who is leading the project, expects the technology to reduce the number of consultants required.
UniCredit reported a 24% reduction in consulting expenditure during the first half of 2026, while Société Générale reported a 9% decline. The figures do not establish how much of either reduction resulted directly from AI.
Commerzbank plans to invest €600 million in AI by 2030, targeting annual savings of €500 million, partly through lower consulting costs.
According to Source Global research cited by the Financial Times, the proportion of surveyed clients expecting to increase their use of Big Four consultants over the following 12 months fell from 80% a year earlier to 55%.
However, consulting demand is not collapsing. Source Global estimated that spending on technology consulting would reach $420 billion in 2026, an increase of 8% on the previous year.
The challenge to billable hours
AI can complete research, analysis, coding and other tasks faster than traditional consulting teams. Clients may therefore question why they should continue paying fees based on the number of people assigned to a project.
KPMG’s Tzekova told CNBC that clients increasingly want to pay for results, but many procurement departments still compare consulting firms using hourly rates and staffing levels.
Outcome-based contracts can link fees to measurable improvements, such as lower costs or higher productivity. However, they also create uncertainty over how firms should measure results, determine their contribution to those results and price the risk of failing to achieve them.
AI introduces additional costs, including computing power, software subscriptions and usage-based charges from technology providers.
Smaller consulting firms see an opportunity to compete
Emiko Caerlewy-Smith of London-based Elixirr told CNBC that her firm focuses on deliverables and outcomes rather than the hours employees spend on projects. She argued that smaller firms may also adapt their operations more quickly than consulting networks employing tens of thousands of professionals.
McKinsey changes how it pays partners
In May, the Financial Times reported that McKinsey was overhauling partner compensation under an initiative called Project Acorn.
The changes would increase the proportion of certain partner awards retained as equity by an estimated three to five percentage points, strengthening the firm’s capital reserves.
McKinsey also plans to bring forward some payments to younger partners, who previously faced lengthy delays before receiving compensation linked to successful projects.
Under traditional arrangements, firms generally bill clients as work progresses. Performance-linked contracts can delay payment until a project achieves agreed savings or other measurable results, sometimes years after the firm incurs the costs of delivering the work.
The shift towards performance-linked fees could force consulting partnerships to retain more capital rather than distribute most of their profits to partners each year.
Project Acorn aims to give McKinsey greater financial flexibility while simplifying a complex compensation system. The changes took more than two years to develop.
PwC restructures its consulting operations
PwC US and PwC India had agreed to combine substantial parts of their consulting operations in a joint venture employing approximately 40,000 people.
The proposed venture would bring together PwC US’s India-based Acceleration Centres and PwC India’s consulting business.
The restructuring addresses a longstanding feature of the Big Four’s operating model: their organisation as networks of legally separate national partnerships.
The arrangement would bring operations belonging to separate national partnerships into a more integrated business, potentially making it easier to coordinate technology investment and international service delivery.
PwC US would hold a majority of the voting rights, while PwC India chair Sanjeev Krishan would become chief executive.
The firms expect to complete the deal in the first half of 2027, subject to regulatory approvals and other conditions.
The Big Four have traditionally used offshore delivery centres to reduce costs by transferring work to locations with lower employment expenses. AI now raises questions about how much of that work will continue to require people.
PwC US chief executive Paul Griggs told the Financial Times that the future lies in AI-enabled managed services rather than traditional labour-intensive outsourcing.
PwC India takes a more expansive view of the opportunity. Krishan argues that companies adopting AI may outsource more work as they seek specialist technology expertise.
AI adoption becomes a leadership expectation
In a March interview with the Financial Times, Griggs warned that partners who resisted AI would have no long-term future at the firm.
He expected senior professionals to identify services that AI could automate and develop new offerings requiring higher levels of human judgement.
PwC also introduced PwC One, a platform designed to give clients access to automated tax and consulting services.
Some services could operate without direct involvement from PwC professionals, with pricing based on subscriptions or usage rather than traditional hourly billing.
His expectations extend to performance management. Rather than measuring success simply by how frequently employees use AI, Griggs said PwC would assess senior professionals through commercial indicators such as revenue and margin per employee. Leaders would also be evaluated on their progress in moving services towards AI-enabled delivery.
Who trains the next generation?
The Big Four’s traditional staffing model has also served as a training system.
Junior professionals perform research, analysis, testing and other foundational tasks while working under the supervision of experienced colleagues. Over time, repeated exposure to client problems helps them develop technical expertise, professional judgement and the ability to recognise when something is wrong.
EY’s global assurance innovation and digital leader, Paul Goodhew, told CNBC that AI could undertake preliminary tasks traditionally assigned to junior auditors, including checking figures against supporting documents.
KPMG’s Tzekova does not believe firms should abandon graduate recruitment. Instead, she expects junior consultants to assume more responsibility earlier in their careers. The challenge is ensuring that employees have enough practical experience to exercise that responsibility effectively.
In July, KPMG US redesigned its audit internship programme, placing greater emphasis on fraud detection, critical thinking and professional judgement.
Nearly 1,000 interns attended training at KPMG Lakehouse, where exercises challenged them to investigate anomalies, deal with incomplete information and question apparently credible conclusions.
Research conducted by KPMG and the University of Texas at Austin illustrates the difficulty. In a study involving 523 early-career professionals working with AI agents, 50.1% improved on the AI’s performance, 25.8% produced broadly equivalent results and 24.1% performed worse than the AI working alone.
EY is pursuing another approach. Its Career Residency programme will allow selected assurance interns to continue working part-time for another eight to 12 months while completing university, combining practical experience with coaching and skills development. The first participants are expected to begin in January 2028.
More recently, PwC announced a critical-thinking certification programme for more than 85,000 employees. The firm plans to invest more than $100 million in the initiative, which will use simulations and practical exercises to help staff evaluate evidence, question assumptions and challenge AI-generated conclusions. PwC expects to begin the rollout in December 2026.
In September, EY US introduced a $100 million rewards programme recognising judgement, adaptability, collaboration, innovation and other skills alongside technology adoption.
Can the partnership pyramid survive?
The Big Four pyramid is not only highly lucrative. It also creates a progression system. Juniors become managers, managers become senior leaders, and some eventually join the partnership.
AI challenges both functions. If technology performs a growing share of routine work, firms may need fewer employees for certain assignments. But reducing the opportunities available to junior professionals could also affect the development of future managers and partners.
In a Big4News Expert Voices contribution, former Arthur Andersen professional William Englehaupt examined how the firm’s structured training model combined technical instruction with practical experience.
He argued that professional-services firms need to rethink not only training but also staffing and promotion structures as AI changes the work available to junior employees.
The challenge is not simply teaching employees how to use AI, but ensuring that they develop the judgement needed to question its conclusions.
In another Big4News Expert Voices interview, academic Patrick Rose described the risk that organisations become increasingly effective at meeting measurable targets while losing the judgement those measures were intended to support.
His concern applies to both AI-assisted professional work and the growing use of performance metrics. A firm could become faster, more productive and more profitable while struggling to determine whether its employees are developing the expertise needed to evaluate complex or unexpected situations.
Training programmes alone cannot replace the experience gained from working through difficult problems, making mistakes and learning from experienced colleagues.
The question is whether the Big Four can preserve the career structure that produces those professionals while reducing their dependence on the junior work that has traditionally supported it.
Related reading
The Big Four’s AI Squeeze — How AI developers are expanding into consulting and competing with their Big Four partners.
PwC to Train 85,000 Staff in Critical Thinking as AI Reshapes Work — PwC’s new programme for strengthening judgement and challenging AI output.
KPMG US Redesigns Audit Training as AI Takes Over Routine Testing — KPMG’s approach to training junior auditors as AI automates routine tasks.
EY US to Keep Assurance Interns for Up to a Year — How EY is extending practical experience for selected assurance interns.
What Arthur Andersen’s Training Model Can Teach the Big Four About AI — William Englehaupt examines the relationship between professional training and the traditional staffing pyramid.
Could Audit Firms Be Improving Their Metrics While Losing Professional Judgement? — Patrick Rose on the limits of performance metrics and the risk of weakening professional judgement.
This article is part of the Big4News Investigations & Analysis series, which examines the structural forces shaping Deloitte, PwC, EY and KPMG.
For more cases involving the Big Four audit firms, explore our Global Big Four Scandal Timeline, which documents major controversies, regulatory investigations, enforcement actions and corporate scandals involving the firms around the world.
About Claudine Cassar

I’m a corporate anthropologist and former Deloitte equity partner. I sold my technology business to Deloitte in 2016 and led the Malta Consulting team for five years. I am the founder and editor of Big4News, which provides independent, clear analysis of PwC, Deloitte, EY, and KPMG — free from corporate spin.
Find me on LinkedIn, X, Instagram, or my author website.
Feel free to reply to this newsletter — I read every reply.



