The UK’s Financial Reporting Council (FRC) has issued new guidance warning that the growing use of artificial intelligence in auditing could create threats to auditor independence, particularly when firms provide clients with insights that go beyond their statutory audit responsibilities.
The guidance addresses how auditors should apply existing ethical requirements when sharing information obtained through AI, data analytics and other technologies.
Where are the independence risks?
In its Ethics and Technology guidance, the FRC identifies several situations in which the use of technology could threaten auditor independence:
Audit work becoming consulting: Sharing findings generated during an audit would generally form part of the audit engagement. However, additional analysis undertaken for other purposes could constitute a non-audit service, even without a separate engagement letter.
Providing free services: Giving clients valuable additional insights without charging for them could create ethical concerns, particularly if the client perceives the work as a favour.
Pursuing future advisory work: Auditors may face a self-interest threat if they provide additional insights to demonstrate their capabilities and position themselves for future consulting engagements.
Management becoming dependent on auditors: Companies may rely on their auditors’ technology to identify weaknesses in internal controls rather than maintaining their own effective monitoring systems. This could draw auditors into management responsibilities.
Self-review threats: If management uses an auditor’s AI-generated insights to prepare financial information, the auditor could subsequently find itself reviewing work influenced by its own technology.
Difficulty challenging AI outputs: Complex or proprietary technologies may produce insights that management cannot independently assess, increasing the risk of excessive reliance on the auditor’s analysis.
What this means for the Big Four
Deloitte, PwC, EY and KPMG are investing heavily in AI-enabled audit tools, with technology increasingly central to how they conduct audits and deliver services to clients.
The FRC’s guidance highlights a challenge facing these firms: technology can increase the value auditors provide to companies, but it can also make the boundary between independent assurance and business advice harder to maintain.
The regulator is not introducing new independence rules. Instead, it is clarifying how the existing Ethical Standard applies as audit technology develops.
The publication follows earlier FRC guidance on generative and agentic AI, issued in March 2026, which focused on managing risks to audit quality and evaluating AI-generated outputs.
The latest guidance addresses a different question: how can auditors share the benefits of increasingly sophisticated technology without compromising their independence?
Related reading
PwC Tells PCAOB to Make AI in Audit Its “Foremost Priority” — PwC urges the US audit regulator to address automation bias, unreliable audit evidence and the growing use of AI in audit work.
The Big Four’s AI Squeeze — How the Big Four’s AI investments are reshaping consulting competition and their relationships with technology providers.
PwC to Train 85,000 Staff in Critical Thinking as AI Reshapes Work — PwC invests more than $100 million in strengthening professional judgement as AI assumes more routine tasks.
Big Four AI Hallucinations: KPMG, Deloitte and EY’s Report Failures — An examination of fabricated references, verification failures and the risks of relying on AI-generated information.
Want to stay up to date on all things Big Four around the world?
Check out the News section and subscribe to Big4News for weekly deep dives and briefings.
About the author: Claudine Cassar is the founder and editor of Big4News, covering audit, consulting, regulation and governance across Deloitte, PwC, EY and KPMG.



