PwC Australia is facing Federal Court proceedings brought by a former client who alleges that misleading, deceptive and negligent tax advice left him and his business facing more than A$15 million in additional tax liabilities, costs and penalties.
Australian businessman Steven Baxter and his company Mandoe, which engaged PwC between 2013 and 2025, have accused the Big Four firm of prioritising its commercial interests over those of its clients.
The proceedings, reported by the Australian Financial Review on 20 November, concern research and development (R&D) tax incentive claims, income-tax advice, a private-equity restructuring and Baxter’s personal tax affairs.
The allegations have not been determined by the court.
Allegations of commercial self-interest
Central to the lawsuit are allegations that PwC failed to adequately disclose the risks associated with Mandoe’s R&D tax incentive claims.
According to the AFR’s account of the court documents, Mandoe alleges that PwC considered the claims highly risky, believed they lacked adequate supporting evidence and anticipated a substantial likelihood of regulatory scrutiny.
The company alleges that PwC nevertheless failed to communicate those concerns because of its financial interest in the fees associated with larger R&D tax offsets.
Mandoe’s R&D claims were initially rejected by the relevant government department in 2018. Although that decision was reversed in 2022, the Australian Taxation Office subsequently disallowed the claims because the supporting records did not adequately distinguish R&D activities from ordinary business operations.
The proceedings also concern separate advice relating to Baxter’s personal tax affairs and the company’s restructuring following a 2019 investment transaction.
In one disputed arrangement, A$10 million was transferred into Baxter’s account in connection with potential R&D tax liabilities. According to the reported allegations, inadequate documentation resulted in the ATO treating the transfer as a dividend, with substantial additional tax consequences.
Mandoe alleges that PwC charged millions of dollars in advisory fees, including fees for work addressing the subsequent ATO disputes.
Former PwC partner previously banned
The lawsuit also involves work associated with former PwC partner Richard Gregg, who headed the firm’s R&D tax incentive practice.
In August 2025, Australia’s Tax Practitioners Board announced that Gregg’s tax-agent registration had been terminated, with a four-year prohibition on reapplying.
The regulator found that Gregg made false or misleading statements in R&D tax incentive applications submitted for multiple clients. It also found deficiencies in his enquiries, assessment of supporting evidence and exercise of professional care.
According to the TPB, the ATO identified cumulative tax shortfalls exceeding A$11 million and penalties exceeding A$800,000 across clients affected by Gregg’s conduct.
The regulator’s detailed disciplinary findings also identified a potential commercial incentive behind the conduct: increasing revenue for PwC’s R&D tax incentive group, which Gregg led.
The TPB concluded that Gregg had breached professional obligations relating to honesty, integrity, competence, clients’ interests and reasonable care.
The regulatory findings concern Gregg’s conduct across multiple clients. They do not establish PwC’s liability in the new proceedings brought by Mandoe and Baxter.
Further professional disciplinary action
Gregg subsequently faced disciplinary proceedings before Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand (CA ANZ).
On 26 March 2026, CA ANZ’s Professional Conduct Committee found that Gregg had breached its professional requirements because he had been subject to an adverse regulatory finding.
The committee ordered him to pay A$7,567 in costs.
As Accounting Times reported in April, Gregg did not concede the underlying TPB findings. The committee relied on the existence of the adverse regulatory determination rather than conducting a fresh adjudication of the underlying conduct.
PwC responds
A PwC spokeswoman confirmed to the AFR that the firm was aware of the proceedings.
The spokeswoman said PwC took the allegations seriously but would not comment on their substance while the matter was before the court.
PwC also pointed to governance, risk-management, accountability and cultural reforms undertaken over recent years.
The lawsuit follows the firm’s wider efforts to rebuild its reputation after the 2023 Australian tax leaks scandal, although the Mandoe proceedings concern separate allegations.
The case brings renewed attention to the responsibilities of major tax advisory firms when the pursuit of client engagements and fee income intersects with professional obligations.
The Federal Court has yet to determine whether PwC breached those obligations in its dealings with Mandoe and Baxter.
Related Reading
Former PwC Tax Partner Banned for Five Years Over Dishonest Conduct
A separate Australian disciplinary case involving former PwC partner Gregory Diamond, including retrospective trust documentation, information withheld from the ATO and arrangements the regulator determined were shams.
Breaking Up the Big Four Is Now on Australia’s Reform Agenda
Australia’s proposals for stronger oversight of major accounting partnerships, including reforms prompted by the PwC tax leaks scandal.
The Hidden Cost of Big Four Governance Failures
An examination of the financial consequences of professional misconduct, including litigation, regulatory penalties, lost clients and pressures on partnership capital.
Who Will Pay for KPMG Australia’s Misconduct?
An analysis of how the financial consequences of governance failures are distributed among partners, employees and the wider professional-services partnership.
Want to stay up to date on all things Big Four around the world?
Check out the News section and subscribe to Big4News for weekly deep dives and briefings.
About the author: Claudine Cassar is the founder and editor of Big4News, covering audit, consulting, regulation and governance across Deloitte, PwC, EY and KPMG.



